{
  "case": "marshak",
  "level": 0,
  "reference_kind": "model-specific",
  "methods": {
    "m1": {
      "time": 0.25,
      "csv": "runs/l0/marshak/m1/plots/marshak/l0/slice.csv",
      "csv_sha256": "a1a2641e22b56b4be2040a54dedb80abb17ea7cfd3bcc6496e06fe6d676c457c",
      "metadata_sha256": "4cc2381dfd103536c23bca0402d6b404e5debf8f95666712224840b4c4ee38d8",
      "leaf_slice_cells": 64,
      "display_slice_pixels": 64,
      "reference_slice_errors": {
        "er": {
          "L1": 0.06979463072113022,
          "L2": 0.19164845714779696,
          "Linf": 0.5418220334447996
        },
        "fx": {
          "L1": 0.004579874726495366,
          "L2": 0.012397817829444557,
          "Linf": 0.03503159786867158
        },
        "fy": {
          "L1": 0.0,
          "L2": 0.0,
          "Linf": 0.0
        },
        "fz": {
          "L1": 0.0,
          "L2": 0.0,
          "Linf": 0.0
        },
        "material_egas": {
          "L1": 0.06735545075928064,
          "L2": 0.18513611233921282,
          "Linf": 0.5234262030027912
        }
      },
      "solver_full_volume_reference_errors": {
        "er": {
          "L1": 0.06979463,
          "L2": 0.1916485,
          "Linf": 0.541822
        },
        "fx": {
          "L1": 0.004579875,
          "L2": 0.01239782,
          "Linf": 0.0350316
        },
        "fy": {
          "L1": 0.0,
          "L2": 0.0,
          "Linf": 0.0
        },
        "fz": {
          "L1": 0.0,
          "L2": 0.0,
          "Linf": 0.0
        },
        "material_egas": {
          "L1": 0.06735545,
          "L2": 0.1851361,
          "Linf": 0.5234262
        }
      },
      "reference_error_scope": "area-weighted saved positive-side slice; not full-volume norms",
      "reference_model": "m1-reference",
      "reference_exact_for_solver": false,
      "reference_sampling": "cell-center point values",
      "reference_note": "The supplied Su\u2013Olson radiation/material reference solves the linear thermal-capacity diffusion problem in normalized units. The saved parameter values define its match to the source model; diffusion and finite-speed M1 transport can differ. Reference values are evaluated at cell centers, without an additional cell-volume average.",
      "reference_sha256": null,
      "reference_generator_sha256": null,
      "reference_diffusion_coefficient": null,
      "reference_kind": "Su-Olson nonequilibrium diffusion reference",
      "radiation_model": "m1",
      "radiation_integrator": "euler",
      "radiation_algorithm_version": 1,
      "radiation_flux_semantics": "evolved_m1_flux",
      "radiation_reduced_c_factor": 1.0,
      "units": {
        "dx": "normalized length",
        "er": "normalized energy density",
        "er_error": "normalized energy density",
        "er_ref": "normalized energy density",
        "fx": "normalized flux",
        "fx_error": "normalized flux",
        "fx_ref": "normalized flux",
        "fy": "normalized flux",
        "fy_error": "normalized flux",
        "fy_ref": "normalized flux",
        "fz": "normalized flux",
        "fz_error": "normalized flux",
        "fz_ref": "normalized flux",
        "material_egas": "normalized energy density",
        "material_egas_error": "normalized energy density",
        "material_egas_ref": "normalized energy density",
        "t": "normalized time",
        "x": "normalized length",
        "y": "normalized length",
        "z": "normalized length"
      },
      "executable_sha256": "82854f6db866ae424dd0b4608d8c6b9b4828b28e4d5f30f48d358097d19ab303",
      "solver_library_sha256": null,
      "source_sha256": {
        "octotiger/amr/gradient.hpp": "58d413487ecbbe95602ac1ec6f356c98630892efe180dcf8352c176bd2c529f5",
        "octotiger/elliptic/composite.hpp": "b9b4f2546c16b2faad29e9d274836734087ed228a20b9bac598b595dcd95df30",
        "octotiger/node_server.hpp": "251393239da4578cce67f36d32c77fb4d6573b510fcde50c9486b8ff2b07a6d6",
        "octotiger/options.hpp": "7e85349a0f9ca6328bae3d037069c417fa426f5c40507c83998c62233a8267a2",
        "octotiger/radiation/ap_flux.hpp": "0ae8a34ac32e552236ab9834dba4561db4b5529c9fab48e884228f7efdf2c262",
        "octotiger/radiation/conservation.hpp": "ee1ba1217456f5dadba7264b1e267631738829160a3ce30dac220581090438f9",
        "octotiger/radiation/fld.hpp": "845bb53693d57a56905f8f933d499280a4fcd95981e8bbb3b7627e30efc10c13",
        "octotiger/radiation/fld_runtime.hpp": "6beca5aa7fa56a4b4a5b4550550cde342bdd85aef126a3931da945d9e48fef25",
        "octotiger/radiation/implicit_source.hpp": "a6900613e9faa8bd89b7eca6f1e2000edbad37fc1c798c78fbda16c41283a9fe",
        "octotiger/radiation/m1.hpp": "799d29b02afed7a6f7e74ce0ff5d877581ca5d7066ae843bd0a69dbb3f79c7c6",
        "octotiger/radiation/marshak_boundary.hpp": "ee871989b9dfef029510c037a959385090e65e6f79abdca99b4bb0136a91ecaf",
        "octotiger/radiation/opacities.hpp": "322784f530ca087966f94ba01c1edc09ccb6985ed89e3ec4eee38e0b18660b29",
        "octotiger/radiation/rad_grid.hpp": "a22d4b1cc3b44e34999b316267f729ee1fd1964e915cb08ae52fa8ef324e65a4",
        "octotiger/test_problems/radiation/hydro_output.hpp": "5444eb3d37b67704ae03d2799f411903a050c5c1c4968bb78988336deb2c746b",
        "octotiger/test_problems/radiation/plot_output.hpp": "ddfff83c321f1f23e3dbacfe11842de5f9c7406975883cc416f12122bc73e47b",
        "octotiger/test_problems/radiation/profiles.hpp": "b51b5e4a0b21d141e8e491a368d0e8ae685c2e9db3e7ee3eb2819e36a17aceeb",
        "src/grid.cpp": "31c5728a84706ce529f42138e4f04fae405ce8a45ceff8f68902039739a0f784",
        "src/io/silo_in.cpp": "6495cbfd3ff6c6e138dbbbc67b6b477454a500b7afddc1591d72419a3340f144",
        "src/io/silo_out.cpp": "be8c15cb297d4f82a0ad74940e45a7ffdd3aeb8e63dc0a534d6281c25a54daf9",
        "src/node_server_actions_1.cpp": "5201b92e2e8e04455f7e1675b1fbfe046fde3144d31746d089c86380a01f80db",
        "src/node_server_actions_2.cpp": "ee5b8e794e5e17d0f2bf21489111344845ee0749b469639a32071fb3174f5398",
        "src/node_server_actions_3.cpp": "87fcf0cc90e9d56d0bdc7d89cd5f5d097961d04577edc1885dacafa645c4d0ec",
        "src/options_processing.cpp": "e397c423c93c89cdd71481c59270162d33fd6808201ca6ccbf9d25f4b48e3725",
        "src/physcon.cpp": "f2defe02d5f0ea9541951cb1aee3201b1bb86eba124fd1c777e9a75dda02a4e6",
        "src/radiation/fld.cpp": "a301946e233e64ea57deaedb1b7d5e0b5a4528cece27f04e4d83569558d87111",
        "src/radiation/iteration.cpp": "86069630821d79cc6d83067435c3deb4a9ab3361208c563b02e6774147316c57",
        "src/radiation/rad_grid.cpp": "e11187c1792f919d43b4fcc223e1079cddcc37dd4b6a5ff6d58c686333840cf1",
        "src/test_problems/marshak/marshak.cpp": "82bb1f3d063391624281a5bc83d154639ce9897b9b170211cfa4ece781ffd704",
        "src/test_problems/radiation/radiation.cpp": "551f393e8454ff0d741588af8701813815aae8af04b42afc5a759473400844de",
        "test_problems/radiation.hpp": "76102aba52767370e1b2bedaa646e755e5e3671742ee183269655b1cf4a5a31f",
        "test_problems/radiation/hydro_benchmarks.hpp": "d2e42bfde0de5c9bde0200453ea40bcefaea91d63455319e08a3e9a5fb5c6c4c",
        "test_problems/radiation/profiles.hpp": "c868e2b5675fac65d3df3c2113c2b4f51de866d550cc039a14d4a4ea4f722b43",
        "test_problems/radiation/reference.hpp": "cc8c794cabbaa89ebd7f30622feec25ae8704bfa99c884b1903e9b129632d748"
      },
      "checkpoint_resume": null
    },
    "fld": {
      "time": 0.25,
      "csv": "runs/l0/marshak/fld/plots/marshak/l0/slice.csv",
      "csv_sha256": "1bf2a48b044f49d896789bca042ecf720ef9f2a0812713f0883826e873164495",
      "metadata_sha256": "562fc6bfb913fe1f0959879274cb8abb66318f47fa91931afb22df66e57f6ef8",
      "leaf_slice_cells": 64,
      "display_slice_pixels": 64,
      "reference_slice_errors": {
        "er": {
          "L1": 0.00639045266382043,
          "L2": 0.01800540346590322,
          "Linf": 0.05092659504290075
        },
        "fx": {
          "L1": 9.825685860089747e-05,
          "L2": 0.0002306628349166596,
          "Linf": 0.0006347323056075421
        },
        "fy": {
          "L1": 9.413097653161014e-24,
          "L2": 3.326410510519012e-23,
          "Linf": 1.602720655341724e-22
        },
        "fz": {
          "L1": 5.79599295806791e-21,
          "L2": 3.058974552952808e-20,
          "Linf": 2.312364682135867e-19
        },
        "material_egas": {
          "L1": 0.006143659007186886,
          "L2": 0.017312046337608324,
          "Linf": 0.04896552097297637
        }
      },
      "solver_full_volume_reference_errors": {},
      "reference_error_scope": "area-weighted saved positive-side slice; not full-volume norms",
      "reference_model": "su-olson-linear-halfspace",
      "reference_exact_for_solver": false,
      "reference_sampling": "cell-center point values",
      "reference_note": "The semi-infinite Su\u2013Olson solution describes constant diffusion and equal linear radiation/material heat capacities. It is a diffusion-limit reference for FLD. Flux limiting, the finite-domain far boundary, cell-center sampling, and discretization can all contribute to its measured discrepancy.",
      "reference_sha256": null,
      "reference_generator_sha256": null,
      "reference_diffusion_coefficient": null,
      "reference_kind": "linear-diffusion-limit",
      "radiation_model": "fld",
      "radiation_integrator": "backward_euler",
      "radiation_algorithm_version": 1,
      "radiation_flux_semantics": "derived_fld_flux",
      "radiation_reduced_c_factor": 1.0,
      "units": {
        "dx": "normalized length",
        "er": "normalized energy density",
        "er_error": "normalized energy density",
        "er_ref": "normalized energy density",
        "fx": "normalized flux",
        "fx_error": "normalized flux",
        "fx_ref": "normalized flux",
        "fy": "normalized flux",
        "fy_error": "normalized flux",
        "fy_ref": "normalized flux",
        "fz": "normalized flux",
        "fz_error": "normalized flux",
        "fz_ref": "normalized flux",
        "material_egas": "normalized energy density",
        "material_egas_error": "normalized energy density",
        "material_egas_ref": "normalized energy density",
        "t": "normalized time",
        "x": "normalized length",
        "y": "normalized length",
        "z": "normalized length"
      },
      "executable_sha256": "82854f6db866ae424dd0b4608d8c6b9b4828b28e4d5f30f48d358097d19ab303",
      "solver_library_sha256": null,
      "source_sha256": {
        "octotiger/amr/gradient.hpp": "58d413487ecbbe95602ac1ec6f356c98630892efe180dcf8352c176bd2c529f5",
        "octotiger/elliptic/composite.hpp": "b9b4f2546c16b2faad29e9d274836734087ed228a20b9bac598b595dcd95df30",
        "octotiger/node_server.hpp": "251393239da4578cce67f36d32c77fb4d6573b510fcde50c9486b8ff2b07a6d6",
        "octotiger/options.hpp": "7e85349a0f9ca6328bae3d037069c417fa426f5c40507c83998c62233a8267a2",
        "octotiger/radiation/ap_flux.hpp": "0ae8a34ac32e552236ab9834dba4561db4b5529c9fab48e884228f7efdf2c262",
        "octotiger/radiation/conservation.hpp": "ee1ba1217456f5dadba7264b1e267631738829160a3ce30dac220581090438f9",
        "octotiger/radiation/fld.hpp": "845bb53693d57a56905f8f933d499280a4fcd95981e8bbb3b7627e30efc10c13",
        "octotiger/radiation/fld_runtime.hpp": "6beca5aa7fa56a4b4a5b4550550cde342bdd85aef126a3931da945d9e48fef25",
        "octotiger/radiation/implicit_source.hpp": "a6900613e9faa8bd89b7eca6f1e2000edbad37fc1c798c78fbda16c41283a9fe",
        "octotiger/radiation/m1.hpp": "799d29b02afed7a6f7e74ce0ff5d877581ca5d7066ae843bd0a69dbb3f79c7c6",
        "octotiger/radiation/marshak_boundary.hpp": "ee871989b9dfef029510c037a959385090e65e6f79abdca99b4bb0136a91ecaf",
        "octotiger/radiation/opacities.hpp": "322784f530ca087966f94ba01c1edc09ccb6985ed89e3ec4eee38e0b18660b29",
        "octotiger/radiation/rad_grid.hpp": "a22d4b1cc3b44e34999b316267f729ee1fd1964e915cb08ae52fa8ef324e65a4",
        "octotiger/test_problems/radiation/hydro_output.hpp": "5444eb3d37b67704ae03d2799f411903a050c5c1c4968bb78988336deb2c746b",
        "octotiger/test_problems/radiation/plot_output.hpp": "ddfff83c321f1f23e3dbacfe11842de5f9c7406975883cc416f12122bc73e47b",
        "octotiger/test_problems/radiation/profiles.hpp": "b51b5e4a0b21d141e8e491a368d0e8ae685c2e9db3e7ee3eb2819e36a17aceeb",
        "src/grid.cpp": "31c5728a84706ce529f42138e4f04fae405ce8a45ceff8f68902039739a0f784",
        "src/io/silo_in.cpp": "6495cbfd3ff6c6e138dbbbc67b6b477454a500b7afddc1591d72419a3340f144",
        "src/io/silo_out.cpp": "be8c15cb297d4f82a0ad74940e45a7ffdd3aeb8e63dc0a534d6281c25a54daf9",
        "src/node_server_actions_1.cpp": "5201b92e2e8e04455f7e1675b1fbfe046fde3144d31746d089c86380a01f80db",
        "src/node_server_actions_2.cpp": "ee5b8e794e5e17d0f2bf21489111344845ee0749b469639a32071fb3174f5398",
        "src/node_server_actions_3.cpp": "87fcf0cc90e9d56d0bdc7d89cd5f5d097961d04577edc1885dacafa645c4d0ec",
        "src/options_processing.cpp": "e397c423c93c89cdd71481c59270162d33fd6808201ca6ccbf9d25f4b48e3725",
        "src/physcon.cpp": "f2defe02d5f0ea9541951cb1aee3201b1bb86eba124fd1c777e9a75dda02a4e6",
        "src/radiation/fld.cpp": "a301946e233e64ea57deaedb1b7d5e0b5a4528cece27f04e4d83569558d87111",
        "src/radiation/iteration.cpp": "86069630821d79cc6d83067435c3deb4a9ab3361208c563b02e6774147316c57",
        "src/radiation/rad_grid.cpp": "e11187c1792f919d43b4fcc223e1079cddcc37dd4b6a5ff6d58c686333840cf1",
        "src/test_problems/marshak/marshak.cpp": "82bb1f3d063391624281a5bc83d154639ce9897b9b170211cfa4ece781ffd704",
        "src/test_problems/radiation/radiation.cpp": "551f393e8454ff0d741588af8701813815aae8af04b42afc5a759473400844de",
        "test_problems/radiation.hpp": "76102aba52767370e1b2bedaa646e755e5e3671742ee183269655b1cf4a5a31f",
        "test_problems/radiation/hydro_benchmarks.hpp": "d2e42bfde0de5c9bde0200453ea40bcefaea91d63455319e08a3e9a5fb5c6c4c",
        "test_problems/radiation/profiles.hpp": "c868e2b5675fac65d3df3c2113c2b4f51de866d550cc039a14d4a4ea4f722b43",
        "test_problems/radiation/reference.hpp": "cc8c794cabbaa89ebd7f30622feec25ae8704bfa99c884b1903e9b129632d748"
      },
      "checkpoint_resume": null
    }
  },
  "status": "matched",
  "direct_slice_difference": {
    "er": {
      "L1": 0.06340422049400286,
      "L2": 0.17364977875848323,
      "Linf": 0.4908954384018989
    },
    "fx": {
      "L1": 0.004481617867894468,
      "L2": 0.012171333130417435,
      "Linf": 0.03439686556306404
    },
    "fy": {
      "L1": 9.413097653161014e-24,
      "L2": 3.326410510519011e-23,
      "Linf": 1.602720655341724e-22
    },
    "fz": {
      "L1": 5.7959929580679085e-21,
      "L2": 3.0589745529528086e-20,
      "Linf": 2.312364682135867e-19
    },
    "material_egas": {
      "L1": 0.06121183149065394,
      "L2": 0.16783008847871136,
      "Linf": 0.47446068202981484
    }
  },
  "difference_kind": "model discrepancy",
  "difference_direction": "fld minus m1",
  "flux_comparison": "derived FLD diagnostic flux minus evolved M1 flux; not momentum error",
  "reference_sampling": "cell-center point values",
  "common_partition": {
    "extent": [
      -1.0,
      1.0,
      -1.0,
      1.0
    ],
    "spacing": 0.25,
    "scope": "piecewise-constant leaf averages on common finest display pixels"
  },
  "plot": "marshak/l0/profiles.png"
}